Salvage 2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X for sale

Browse 104 salvage 2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X vehicles from IAA and Copart — live auctions and ended sales, with photos, VIN, damage and last bid.

Filters (3)

Filters

Current & archive104 Current27 Archive77

All sources

IAA Canada5

IAA USA99

Buy Now only Clean title Runs & drives Has keys ≤ 100k mi Ending today Next 48 hours This week Light repair Pure sale (high bid wins)

104 results

List Grid Map

10 matching lots arrived in the last 7 daysClear filters

Show est. all-in

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63629H****** · 46128571

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Flood
Storage location: Hartford (Connecticut)
Title status: Salvage
Status: Runs & drives

Oct 15, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63609H****** · 46301455

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Templeton (Massachusetts)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

Oct 16, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63619H****** · 46290081

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 102194 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Avenel New Jersey (New Jersey)
Title status: Clear

Buy now US$1,000Oct 19, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61659H****** · 46051592

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 149368 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Chicago-West (Illinois)
Title status: Clear

Buy now US$575Oct 19, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63659H****** · 45730501

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 149532 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Eugene
Title status: Salvage

Buy now US$800Oct 19, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63619H****** · 46138566

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 211772 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Eugene
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

Buy now US$675Oct 19, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61609G****** · 46251543

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Odometer: 1 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Scranton (Pennsylvania)
Title status: Clear

Buy now US$725Oct 20, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63649H****** · 46149868

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 204445 mi
Primary damage: All Over
Storage location: Taunton
Title status: Non-Repairable
Status: Runs & drives

Oct 20, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63629H****** · 46142566

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 230948 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Pulaski (Virginia)
Title status: Clear

Buy now US$550Oct 20, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61619H****** · 46002838

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 283674 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Spokane (Washington)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

Buy now US$425Oct 20, 20260h 00m

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61699H****** · 46007607

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 1 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Portage (Wisconsin)
Title status: Non-Repairable

Buy now US$475Oct 21, 20260h 00m

JF2SH61649G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61649G****** · 46335452

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Odometer: 146857 mi
Primary damage: Left Rear
Storage location: Dundalk (Maryland)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63619H****** · 46353413

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Portland - Gorham (Maine)

Auction not assigned

JF2SH63689H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63689H****** · 46319775

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 107440 mi
Primary damage: Left Rear
Storage location: York Springs (Pennsylvania)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

JF2SH63649G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63649G****** · 46321433

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Buffalo (New York)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

JF2SH63679H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63679H****** · 46324745

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Templeton (Massachusetts)

Auction not assigned

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63659H****** · 46275866

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 212193 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Spokane (Washington)

Auction not assigned

JF2SH636X9H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH636X9H****** · 46277057

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Right Side
Storage location: Phoenix (Arizona)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63649H****** · 46289909

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Taunton (Massachusetts)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63619H****** · 46227557

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 222746 mi
Primary damage: Left Front
Storage location: Boston - Shirley (Massachusetts)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63619H****** · 46251272

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 108286 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Providence (Rhode Island)

Auction not assigned

JF2SH61689H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61689H****** · 46235118

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 141515 mi
Primary damage: Right Rear
Storage location: Metro DC (Maryland)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63689H****** · 46241097

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Columbus (Ohio)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH636X9H****** · 46243483

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Seattle (Washington)
Title status: Clear
Status: Engine starts

EndedOct 7, 2026

JF2SH61679H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61679H****** · 46176980

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Rear
Storage location: Davenport (Iowa)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

JF2SH63699H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Upcoming

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63699H****** · 46176705

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Lake City (Georgia)
Status: Runs & drives

Auction not assigned

JF2SH61609H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61609H****** · 45621019

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · Automatic · Gasoline

Odometer: 110366 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Boston - Shirley (Massachusetts)
Title status: None
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61699H****** · 46144504

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 250440 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Sacramento (California)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 14, 2026

JF2SH63689G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63689G****** · 46288265

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Seattle (Washington)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 14, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61689H****** · 46228397

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Seattle (Washington)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 14, 2026

Ended

IAA Canada

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61609H****** · 40084776

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · Auto

Odometer: 186549 km
Primary damage: Front
Storage location: Abbotsford, BC
Title status: Repairable
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 2, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63679H****** · 46182633

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 177402 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Altoona (Pennsylvania)
Title status: Salvage

EndedOct 14, 2026

JF2SH63639H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63639H****** · 46197714

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 112613 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Minneapolis/St. Paul (Minnesota)
Title status: Salvage
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 14, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63699H****** · 46180694

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 179666 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Syracuse (New York)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 1, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61619H****** · 46182529

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: East Bay (California)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 1, 2026

JF2SH63689H715838 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA Canada

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63689H715838 · 12659203X

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · Auto

Odometer: 303978 km
Primary damage: Possible Mech.
Storage location: Stoney Creek, ON
Title status: None
Status: Doesn't start

EndedSep 28, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61689H****** · 46134825

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 146163 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Syracuse (New York)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 24, 2026

JF2SH63669H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63669H****** · 46131770

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Taunton (Massachusetts)
Title status: Non-Repairable
Status: Engine starts

EndedOct 13, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61659H****** · 46139162

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 166154 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: East Bay (California)
Title status: Salvage
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 8, 2026

JF2SH61629G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61629G****** · 45981099

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Odometer: 129258 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Anchorage
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61609H****** · 46090857

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Raleigh (North Carolina)
Title status: Clear
Status: Engine starts

EndedSep 23, 2026

JF2SH61679G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61679G****** · 46087434

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Albany (New York)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 22, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63669H****** · 46064411

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 102812 mi
Primary damage: Right Side
Storage location: Kansas City (Kansas)
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61689H****** · 46080984

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 1 mi
Primary damage: Unknown
Storage location: Dallas (Texas)

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63679H****** · 46090408

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Hartford (Connecticut)
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

JF2SH61639H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61639H****** · 46062304

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 187659 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Portland - Gorham (Maine)
Title status: Salvage
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

JF2SH61649H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61649H****** · 46064424

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Rollover
Storage location: Erie (Pennsylvania)
Title status: Salvage

EndedOct 1, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63609H****** · 45938589

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 204326 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Longview (Texas)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 17, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63669H****** · 46056405

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Templeton (Massachusetts)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 11, 2026

JF2SH61629H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61629H****** · 46075264

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 184951 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Eugene (Oregon)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedOct 5, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63659H****** · 46060166

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 92977 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Nashville (Tennessee)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 24, 2026

JF2SH616X9H****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH616X9H****** · 46047244

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Portage (Wisconsin)
Status: Engine starts

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61689H****** · 46052987

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 65074 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 8, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61639H****** · 46008999

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: All Over
Storage location: Concord (North Carolina)
Title status: Salvage
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 28, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63609H****** · 46016616

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 140000 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Philadelphia (Pennsylvania)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 4, 2026

JF2SH61619G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61619G****** · 45994275

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Odometer: 1 mi
Primary damage: Left Side
Storage location: Lexington (South Carolina)
Title status: Salvage

EndedSep 30, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61659H****** · 46014235

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Seattle (Washington)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 9, 2026

JF2SH63679G****** 2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63679G****** · 45982047

2.5L H-4 VVT, regular , 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Manual

Odometer: 183434 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Newburgh (New York)
Title status: Clear
Status: Runs & drives

EndedSep 16, 2026

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH61609H****** · 45760494

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · Automatic · Gasoline

Odometer: 141871 mi
Primary damage: Front End
Storage location: Hartford (Connecticut)
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

IAA USA

2009 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X

JF2SH63649H****** · 45789388

2.5L H-4 VVT, 170HP · 4 cyl · All-Wheel Drive · Automatic

Odometer: 145545 mi
Primary damage: Normal Wear & Tear
Storage location: Staten Island (New York)
Status: Runs & drives

Ended

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X price data

Median bid: $675
Average bid: $774
Bid range: $425 – $1,650

Based on 104 archived lots — USD-normalized, last observed bid (not a guaranteed sale price).

Browse by year

2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004

How much does a salvage 2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X sell for?

Across 104 salvage 2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X lots, the median winning-side bid is $675 and the average is $774 (range $425 to $1,650). Pre-loss retail value averages —. Prices are USD-normalized from IAA and Copart; a sold lot’s figure is the last observed bid, not a guaranteed sale price.